A downy woodpecker clinging to a wire suet cage feeder eating suet in a natural woodland setting

Best Suet Feeders

Quick answer (Updated June 2026): The Stokes Select Double Suet Feeder is the best suet feeder. It holds two standard suet cakes, has a roof that sheds rain and snow, and a tail-prop support that lets woodpeckers brace naturally while feeding. If starlings are emptying your suet in hours, switch to an upside-down design that only clings-capable birds can access.

Our top pick: The Stokes Select Double Suet Feeder is the best suet feeder because its double-cake capacity means fewer trips outside in winter, the roof keeps rain off the suet and the tail-prop design lets woodpeckers brace comfortably while feeding. Across owner reviews, this model draws the most woodpecker and nuthatch visits while producing the least wasted suet compared to basic cage designs.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

Our Top Pick: Stokes Select Double Suet Feeder

Holds two standard suet cakes. Metal roof sheds rain and snow. Tail-prop support for woodpeckers. Metal construction resists squirrel damage.

Check Price on Amazon

Product Capacity Design
Stokes Select Double 2 cakes Cage with roof Check Price
Heath Upside-Down 1 cake Upside-down Check Price
Woodlink Cage 1 cake Basic cage Check Price
Kingsyard Starling-Proof 2 cakes Caged entry Check Price
Suet, and the starling problem
One design choice locks starlings out and nothing else does
Birds suet brings in
woodpeckers, nuthatches, chickadees, wrens
The bird it also brings in
starlings, in numbers
The only reliable fix
an upside-down feeder
Why it works
starlings will not feed inverted, woodpeckers will
Cakes a buffet-style feeder holds
4
Summer suet
use a no-melt blend above 90 F
Tail prop
matters for larger woodpeckers
Cage size to exclude grackles
1.5 in mesh

Suet is treated as winter food and it is not. The birds that want it most are feeding young in spring, which is exactly when a no-melt cake earns its price difference.

Plumelore earns a commission on qualifying purchases through the Amazon links on this page, at no extra cost to you. Picks are chosen on performance and suitability, not on commission.

Chart comparing the price of three suet feeders
Upside-down feeders cost a few dollars more and are the only ones starlings will not use.
Cage, tail prop or upside down, and what each one changes (source: Mark’s Backyard Birds)

Upside-Down vs. Cage Style

Upside-down suet feeders hang the cake facing the ground, so birds must cling underneath to feed. This excludes starlings, grackles and blue jays, who cannot feed while hanging upside-down. Woodpeckers, nuthatches and chickadees have no problem with this orientation. If starlings are devouring your suet in hours, switch to an upside-down design. Suet works best as part of a layered feeding station; see our bird feeder guide by type for the best companion feeders for woodpeckers and nuthatches. Pair your suet feeder with black oil sunflower in a tube feeder and you will cover the full range of clinging and perching species. Our bird seed guide covers which seed blends pair best with a suet setup.

Feeder Style Capacity What it is for
Nature’s Way cedar, upside down Upside down 1 cake The starling lock-out, in cedar that survives a few winters
Birds Choice upside down Upside down 4 cakes Same exclusion, four times the capacity, for a busy yard
More Birds Suet Buffet Open cage, metal roof 4 cakes Cheapest per cake, and it will feed starlings too
St Albans Bay Suet Plus variety Suet cakes Variety pack A pack of flavours to find out what your yard actually eats
Check current price
Nature’s Way cedar, upside downon AmazonBirds Choice upside downon AmazonMore Birds Suet Buffeton AmazonSt Albans Bay Suet Plus varietyon Amazon

Prices move, and stock does too. Each of these opens the product page on Amazon in a new tab.

Starting suet in a new yard
Five steps
1Hang it near cover
Woodpeckers approach from a trunk, not across open lawn.
2Start with a plain rendered cake
Fruit and nut blends attract more of everything, starlings included.
3Give it two weeks
Suet is the slowest feeder type to get found. It is not broken.
2 weeks
4Go upside down if starlings arrive
Do not wait. A starling flock trains other starlings.
5Switch to no-melt in summer
Melted suet turns rancid and coats feathers.
above 90 F
Suet is not only winter food, and the summer version is different (source: Birdfeeding with Kurtis)

Frequently Asked Questions

Where should I hang a suet feeder?

Near tree trunks or thick branches where clinging birds naturally forage. Woodpeckers feel safest feeding close to a vertical surface they can escape to. Avoid open areas.

Does suet go bad in summer?

Yes, raw suet melts above 70 F and can turn rancid. Switch to no-melt suet doughs in summer or take suet feeders down during hot months. They are primarily a cold-weather food source.

Written by the Plumelore Team

Our picks are based on manufacturer specifications, birding organization guidance, and aggregated owner reviews. See our research approach.